|
Apr 15/06 - Shabbat Chol
Hamoed Pesach
Commentary by
Rabbi Alan Green
“(Moses) said: ‘Let
me behold Your
Glory!’ (God)
answered: ‘I will
make all of My
goodness pass before
you, and I will
proclaim before you
the name Lord: I
will be gracious to
whomever I am
gracious; and show
mercy to whomever I
show mercy. But you
cannot see My face,
for a human being
may not see Me and
live.’ And the Lord
said: ‘See, there is
a place near Me.
Station yourself on
the rock and, as My
Presence passes by,
I will put you in a
cleft of the rock,
and shield you with
My hand until I have
passed by. Then I
will take My hand
away, and you will
see My back. But My
face may not be
seen.’”
Exodus 33:17-23
This particular
section of the Torah
was chosen as a
special reading for
the Sabbath of the
intermediate days of
Pesach
because the Feast of
Passover is
mentioned
specifically in Ex.
34:25. But this
passing reference to
Pesach is
surrounded by much
weightier material,
the inclusion of
which cannot be
accidental.
All of this takes
place in the
immediate wake of
the sin of the
Golden Calf. And one
wonders, how could
the Israelites have
been so foolish as
to lapse into
idolatry? They had
experienced the Ten
Plagues, the parting
of the Sea of Reeds,
and revelation at
Mt. Sinai. How could
they have abandoned
the God of Israel,
scant weeks after
experiencing the
greatest miracles in
Jewish history?
God and Moses both
grasp the severity
of the situation.
The whole plan of
rescuing Israel from
Egypt is plunged
into deep confusion.
The mission
statement of the
rescue attempt—that
“You shall have no
other gods before
Me,” has now been
called into
question.
Moses responds by
grinding up the
Golden Calf, casting
it into the water
supply, and having
the people drink it.
In light of both the
traditional and
modern uses of gold
as a healing
modality, this is an
interesting gesture.
Perhaps Moses wishes
to heal the people,
as much as he wishes
to punish them.
Moses also commands
the Levites to kill
the perpetrators of
the rebellion on the
spot.
God, from His side,
threatens to
exterminate the
whole nation, and
make a new, more
faithful people out
of Moses. To his
everlasting great
credit, Moses talks
God out this plan.
And it is possible
that God fully
intended that Moses
should talk him out
of it. As a result,
God is able to
maintain Himself as
the merciful God of
all mankind. And
Moses is able to
demonstrate, for all
time, that effective
leadership means
making huge
allowances for human
frailty.
Now, as we arrive at
the passage quoted
above, God and Moses
are debating the
merits of whether
God should lead the
people directly or
indirectly. God
points out that His
is a dangerous
presence, and that
it makes no sense
for Him to dwell
among the people if
they are as prone to
confusion as they
have just
demonstrated
themselves to be.
Moses argues that if
God doesn’t lead
directly, the Jewish
people will
immediately cease to
be able to fulfill
their mission as
God’s people.
God allows Moses to
talk him out of any
alternative
arrangement—again,
fully intending that
Moses should succeed
in doing so. Now,
Moses seeks to
parlay these
victories into a
direct vision of the
Glory of God. What
is the nature of
that Glory, and why
does Moses want to
gain insight into
it?
The word KAVOD
in Hebrew usually
means, “honour,” or
“respect.” However,
when applied to God,
the connotation
changes. In that
context, the
relationship of
KAVOD to God is
like the
relationship between
light and the sun.
“M’LO KOL HA-ARETZ
K’VODO”—”The
fullness of all the
earth is God’s
Glory,” says the
prophet Isaiah. In
other words, God’s
KAVOD is
something that
“shines,” or
permeates throughout
God’s creation.
Permeating all,
giving life and
being to all, God’s
Glory could be
compared to the
colourless sap of a
tree. Having no real
form or substance of
its own, the
colourless sap is
nevertheless
responsible for all
the vibrancy and
colour of the tree.
Similarly, God’s
Glory. It is the
formless, invisible
influence that makes
things the way they
are, and causes
things to happen the
way they do.
There is therefore,
a strong hint that
what Moses wants to
know is exactly what
we all want to know:
why does the world
work the way it
does? Why do things
happen the way they
happen? Science
answers many of
these questions on
the level of Nature
and its processes.
But the most
intriguing aspect of
this question always
has to do with human
destiny. Why do bad
things happen to
good people? Why do
good things happen
to bad people? And
so on.
In this short
passage, God gives
three answers to
these implied
questions:
Answer #1: “I
will be gracious to
whomever I am
gracious, and I will
show mercy to
whomever I show
mercy.” Here, God
seems to be saying
that while we cannot
know the wherefores
and why’s of what
happens to us, we
should rest assured
that all of it—the
good, the bad, and
the ugly of
it—ultimately comes
from God, and that
He punishes and
rewards human beings
with aplomb. After
all, He is God.
Answer #2:
“You cannot see My
face, for man may
not see Me and
live.” Notice what
God is NOT saying
here. God never says
that Moses couldn’t
see His face—only
that he couldn’t see
God’s face and LIVE.
In other words,
there may well come
a time when we will
be able to see
“God’s face”
directly, and be in
a position to fathom
the precise reason
why things happen
the way they do. But
not in this world,
or this lifetime.
Answer #3: “I
will put you in a
cleft of the
rock…and you will
see My back; but My
face must not be
seen.” Just because
we can’t see God’s
face and live,
doesn’t mean that
we’re totally blind.
It’s possible at
least to see God’s
back, and still
retain our body,
mind, and senses in
the physical
universe. And what
is God’s back? After
God has done what
he’s done, and we
look back at all
that has happened to
us, perhaps we can
begin to understand
why God decided to
do the things that
he did.
Very often, in
retrospect, we
perceive the events
of our life very
differently than in
the immediate
present. Even
experiences of
intense pain and
deep confusion, when
seen in the context
of our lives as a
whole, can be
accepted as lessons
that we needed to
learn when they are
analyzed in present
tense. Maybe this is
what it means to
“see God’s back.”
Shabbat Shalom and
Chag Sameach.
|